What Could Have Been

A sore spot with myself and with many of you was the sudden demise of the TVIX trade we entered on March 14, 2012.  We entered this trade based on a base that was forming on the VIX volatility index.  The stock market at the time was on an unbelievable tear at a better than 50% annual return which we all believed was unsustainable.  That happened to mark a high in the stock market.

It also market the low of the VIX.  On the day we purchased TVIX, the VIX was near its March 16 low of 14.39.  Today, the VIX reached a high as of this writing of 26.02 for a staggering return of just over 80%.  We should have realized a gain in just under 3 months of near 150%.  Unfortunately as you well know, we as a club and I myself are underwater on this position still.  Click here to learn more about what happened to TVIX.

The good news for this position is that the market is tanking, and TVIX is rallying.  The S&P 500 is now below where it started the year and fear is growing.  That said, it is but a matter of time before Uncle Ben provides the economy a third round of QE which should remove fear from the market place and send TVIX lower again.  I expect there are thousands of trapped investors such as ourselves who will welcome an opportunity to get out, much like the trapped silver longs were last summer.

The BLIC gave me discretion to exit this position as conditions warranted.  When/if the VIX moves into the target area, my plan is for us to exit out of this position with a small gain or loss.

I do wish to remind the club that the risk on this trade was defined at the onset.  We only risked a little more than 1% of the total portfolio value on this position.  Position sizing is one way to manage risk, along with stops which we have used with mostly poor results.  Had this instrument performed as advertised, it would have essentially been a hedge against our unprotected long positions in the portfolio, which is another way to manage risk against what is happening today.

Does This Look Like A Great Time To Buy?

I am not going to push the bearish case or the bullish case.  Rather, I wish to present the wait case.  Right now is not a great time to be stepping in and buying.  Yes, I know the market has been on a tear, but that euphoria is normally followed by reality at some point.  Case in point, lets look at a chart on the S&P 500.

Take a look at the NASDAQ.  Multiple warning signs show on this index.

The dollar is also well outside the normal timing band for a bounce.  Any sort of pull back from an already stretched stock market should cause a large surge in the dollar, which will also pressure commodities, including agricultural commodities, oil, and precious metals.

There have been several large SOS days over the past week as well.  Combined together, things look very ripe for a pull back in the market at the very least.  Next month should be a better opportunity to get more aggressive with stock purchases.

Look For Familiar Patterns In Stocks and Commodities

The road map for how the dollar is trading was actually created back in 2008.  If you look at the chart I have put below, you can see how similar the patterns are at this point.  I have divided the chart into sections that correspond with the dollar cycles.

Stocks do not necessarily trade opposite of the dollar, bu tthey tend to trend with it.  The chart below shows 2008 S&P in an unmistakable pattern that follows with the 2008 dollar.  Barring any significant news such as Bernanke changing fed policy, I would not bet against something similar playing out.


And commodities should work the same way.  Sorry Dennis, but this corn chart is why fertilizer will come down, and so will MOS.

Mosaic got smoked back in 2008.